On Saturday evening, well multitasking a trip back home, I successfully (per my opinion) completed my first fantasy football redraft of the 2024 season. In my 12-team PPR league with 1 QB, 2 RBs, 2 WRs, 1 TE, 1 Flex, and the less important Defense and Kicker, I started my draft from the 9 slot.
In my preparation, I determined 8 players to be desirable for the position I was in, so I figured I would get no one I wanted in this slot. Based on this league I ranked the players as follows: 3 RBs (McCaffrey, Hall, and Robinson) and 5 WRs (Lamb, Chase, Jefferson, St. Brown, and Hill). I was doubtful I would get 1, so I was prepared for one of Jonathan Taylor, Jahmyr Gibbs, AJ Brown, and Garrett Wilson. With 2 picks to go until I was up, the seventh slot of draft’s options included Chase and Jefferson, if one fell to me I was going to be thrilled. And then Chase went 7th, but in my shock Jonathan Taylor went 8th, sitting there in front of me was Justin Jefferson. His QB situation isn’t popular, but we’ve seen talented, young wide receivers overcome their QB situation. Best example that comes to behind – Calvin Johnson in 2008 had 1331 receiving yards with 12 receiving touchdowns and a top 3 finish at his position. The negative was he had only 78 receptions on 151 targets, but the positive was he excelled on a team that went 0-16 with quarterbacks Dan Orlovsky, Daunte Culpepper, and Jon Kitna. Yeah, there’s a chance that AJ Brown or Garrett Wilson outplays Jefferson, but Jefferson could outplay anyone of his top 5 counterparts at the position.
As I prepared for the 2nd pick, draft slot 16, my attention was on the running back position. The only way I would go into wide receiver was for the aforementioned Brown and Wilson (they were of course gone). My preferred running back was Gibbs (gone) and another top running back Barkley was also drafted. At my pick, my choices were down to Travis Etienne and Kyren Williams. I went with Travis Etienne, I had him ranked in a higher tier, so it wasn’t much for me to think about. But here’s my logic, Kyren Williams’ numbers are what you expect from a running back and I wish Etienne would get more carries, but this logic is based on 2023, not 2024. Williams has a highly draft, national champion, in Blake Corum, in his backfield. The Rams offense is a revolving door of running backs especially in the time of Sean McVey. Consider the following running backs who’ve been fantasy relevant on the Rams in the last five years – Todd Gurley, Darrell Henderson, Sony Michel, Cam Akers, and now Kyren Williams. Yes, Williams, had the most dominant season, but McVey is quick to play the hot hand, so don’t be surprised in a must win Week 13 matchup Corum is out carrying Williams 20 to 6. With Etienne, I don’t think there’s many other legitimate options, and I think with the targets going to just Engram and Kirk with Ridley gone, the offense will go more and more to the run.
To not go too far, I won’t spend much more time with the rest of my draft, but I do have a few other points I want to make. Last year, I chased late RB2’s that were undervalued, this year, I realized that there are more WRs I would be comfortable with at WR2 and the Flex then at RB2, so I need to take a RB when I can. In the 3rd round, my highest ranked running back is Rachaad White, another running back I love for his workhorse opportunities. In the 4th round, I was content taking a wide receiver, the best on my board was DK Metcalf, but then sitting there my number 1 tight end, and with only Laporta off the board, I had to take my namesake-ish in Travis Kelce. Down the stretch last year, including the playoffs, Kelce was putting up WR1 numbers, yes, he’s a year older, but the Chiefs offense still goes through him and coming into this season he is much healthier than he was last year (causing his very slow start). And my bet paid off when Andrews, McBride, Kincaid, and Engram followed close behind. Basically, if I didn’t take Kelce, I would have gone Engram, but I would have been devastated to miss him by a single pick.
Now on to the rest of my draft, I looked for players who could be RB1 or WR1 based on talent, past experience, and in some cases opportunity. The players I collected in slot were Tee Higgins (motivated for a new contract and Chase’s absences), George Pickens (talent overcoming the QB situation), Austin Ekeler (he did before, he could do it again), Keenan Allen (not too long ago a WR1 with an incredible opportunity for one last ride before his last contract), Nick Chubb (probably at the top of the list of athletes you trust returning to form from massive injuries), Courtland Sutton (the passing offense has upgraded and he’s the number 1 with lionshare of catches). There is one position I didn’t mention, and it is the one I kept waiting for – the quarterback slot. Last year in this league I had Josh Allen who fell to be late in the early 4th round (like Kelce did this year). This season he went in the third along with Josh Allen and then Jalen Hurts in the fourth before I took Kelce. I did look at Patrick Mahomes and Lamar Jackson before Travis Kelce, but I felt Kelce was too good at his position to pass on, which considering my options would have been George Kittle or Kyle Pitts, I am happy I avoided that significant deviation. I then watched Mahomes, Jackson, and Anthony Richardson go and I kept waiting. My only potential regret is I probably should have took Burrow in the 5th and waiting on wide receiver in the 6th (Higgins could have still been there), because I just missed Burrow by a single pick (a player who I think could win the MVP in 2024, I will certainly get him elsewhere). From there, I didn’t mind Kyler Murray, but when I looked closer at his stats in a 6-pt passing TD league, I felt there were other QB’s worthy of that slot. I kept waiting and waiting and finally my move, I took Caleb Williams in the 10th, Justin Herbert in the 16th, and then Jared Goff in free agency (with Chubb on IR). I think 1 of those guys are bound to be a top 8 QB with consideration of great opportunity (Williams), great talent (Herbert), and a mixture of both (Goff).
In the end, I deem this a successful draft for the first of the season, I give myself a B+. I worry a little bit about the QB slot and feel I have a slight gap at WR2 / Flex, but I am thrilled with my depth and how I managed the RB / TE position. Now, I just wait, a week and half to fret lineup decisions and see the scores roll-in, but for a few more leagues, I will enjoy the best part of fantasy football, draft season!